Life So Far
Just Some Letters

When I hear the acronym “NCSY”, several thoughts come to mind- family, friends, Judaism. Most importantly, those four short letters mean “hope”; hope in a promising future, whatever that may be for an individual.  NCSY has long been, for me, a safe house from the harsh realities of this world.  

I started NCSY freshman year at the request of an acquaintance.  I was shy and poorly spoken; just thinking about meeting and carrying out conversations with new people made me queasy.  Further, although I graduated a private Jewish middle school, I had no intention of becoming a public Jew in high school.  In fact, my goal was quite the opposite… to hide it.  

When I hear the word “brother”, I think of betrayal, unfathomable hatred, and illogical choices.  The feelings he generated keep me up at night, and trigger the analogous nightmares I visit each night I can sleep.  I have come to grips with reality that nothing will ever upset me as much as how I feel when Josh comes to mind.  Since this is true, I am forced to ask myself a question; why do small things upset me so much?  The answer is blatantly obvious and simple: the disconcerting memory of my brother is constantly in my thoughts.  It only takes a small negative to relive all I despise.


As the issue with my brother began to truly unfold (Thanksgiving 2010), I needed a confidant.  I turned to one adviser in particular who I have still yet to thank.  Upon hearing my story, he made sure to call me every night to listen to my kvetching, he gave me advice, and he made sure I never went to bed angry.  I recently phoned the director of my region of NCSY (Upstate New York), Marc Fein, to glorify my adviser, now friend.  Marc responded with, “it’s an NCSY mesorah (chain of tradition).”  He’s right; that is why NCSY is so effective in developing a well rounded individual, no matter his or her personal experiences.  The NCSY culture is one of supportiveness so that even distraught youth may bloom into exactly what I wasn’t freshman year.    


Day in and day out I fight with myself over the existence of Josh as my brother.  What is the definition of “brother?”  A biologist would say, “a male with characteristics selected from the same gene pool as another.”  The definition is different from a psychological/emotional viewpoint.  My brother should be my hero who steers me in the right direction.  He should value our relationship as siblings above all else (besides for his filial piety).  He should teach me through his mistakes so that I might have an even brighter future.  This definition is, predictably, in contrast to that harsh reality that is my brother.  


I have written most of the details of Josh’s sins in previous posts (a few are left out because they are still too painful to be written), so I am merely referencing them.  My point is this: NCSY is beneficial, and almost essential, to a young man’s growth and development.  I do not know what I would be without the comforting support of NCSY (particularly my adviser/role model going on two years), but I am certain that it would not include being well-spoken, optimistic, or a person with qualities worth admiring.  In ways that friends, family members and fellow NCSY goers have yet to understand, NCSY has drastically changed my future.  Spiritually, I have gone from casual observer to regular participant; particularly in reference to my wearing a yarmulke.  Further, I am no longer doomed to be emotionally brittle.  On the contrary, I am more secure in my sense of self identity than I have ever been.  As opposed to the pathetic life that my “brother” had laid out for me, I have a bright future ahead and so much thanks to give.

Hi Ben--I read about you in the IGNITE magazine from NSCY. You may or may not know that about 10-15 kids from Buffalo became frum thru NCSY in the early 70's, mostly thru the influence of a man named Ezra Berkowitz. Lots and lots of frum Jews now, plus their children and grandchildren. Best of luck to you.
Anonymous
eyulpan:

Ulpan @ Eretz Yisrael is a new member blog of Eretz Yisrael which aims at providing basic Hebrew lessons to anyone who has an interest in Israel, Judaism, or just languages in general. We hope you like our new blog!
We will first go right down to the basics of the Alef-bet, with providing you with a new letter every day, so you can slowly build up a base of firm foundation, ready for the more juicy parts of The Holy Language!
The first letter is coming up very soon!

eyulpan:

Ulpan @ Eretz Yisrael is a new member blog of Eretz Yisrael which aims at providing basic Hebrew lessons to anyone who has an interest in Israel, Judaism, or just languages in general. We hope you like our new blog!

We will first go right down to the basics of the Alef-bet, with providing you with a new letter every day, so you can slowly build up a base of firm foundation, ready for the more juicy parts of The Holy Language!

The first letter is coming up very soon!

eretzyisrael:

Kahana Tsadak Israeli rap

Truth and Authenticity

Anti-Israel is defined as the delegitimization of the state of Israel.  What is delegitimization?  It is not, contrary to popular belief, just about accepting Israel as the Jewish state.  It is believing that Israel’s actions are illegal/morally inexcusable.  Now, before I enter into my own public-private discussion about my belief in Israel’s rights, I must point out that I disagree with certain aspects of Israel and her government’s policies (after all, Israel is a full fledged democracy), but I will never insinuate in any way that Israel has stolen land/must give back land because no land was taken unjustly.   

People are often convinced that all Israel must do to achieve peace, or at least to reignite the peace process, is to withdraw completely from the West Bank.  Such a notion represents, with all due respect, complete ignorance.  As those who understand/are concerned with Middle Eastern politics would know, Israel did not even inhabit an inch of the West Bank prior to 1967.  From 1948 (the year Israel became an independent nation) onward Israel has been hated by all Arab nations, most Arabs in general, and the “Palestinian” people (I use quotes because “Palestine” was never even a country..an indisputable fact).  Israel is delegitimized because she is the one and only Jewish nation in this world, compared to the fifty-seven Islamic states, and twenty Christian states.    

Okay, now I shall precede.  In a war of self defense, Israel took over the West Bank because the many attacking Arab armies used that ground to shoot down on civilians (the West Bank is on a higher plain, making it very important, from a military standpoint).  Anyways, if Jewish “settlers” in the West Bank is considered the roadblock to peace, explain to me why the Palestinian people did not accept Israel prior to 1967!  One would assume that the West Bank is the root cause of no peace between Israel and “Palestine”, but that is clearly not the case.  Believing otherwise is ignoring the part of history where Israel had no control over that area. 

Further, Israel gave the Gaza strip to the Palestinians.  It was meant as an act of peace.  How did the Palestinians reciprocate Ariel Sharon’s meaningful act of giving?  They began and still do shoot thousands of rockets into civilian areas within the defined borders of Israel.  Let Gaza serve as a testing ground for further land swap deals.  The idea of “land for peace” is only an idea…not the solution.  When a people refuse to acknowledge your right to exist by any means, it is ludacris to believe in their ever changing demands.  

Fact:  Israel is the only Jewish state.  Fact:  Palestine was never a recognized country.  Fact:  The West Bank was not “occupied” until the 1967 war of self defense.  Fact:  Few Arab nations and few Palestinians have accepted Israel in general.  Fact:  Innocent Israelis die everyday as a result of the Palestinian control of Gaza.  

Facts are unbiased approaches to seemingly obvious questions.  Do not ignore history.  Do not ignore facts.  Yes, Israel is not always in the right, but spreading false ideas make peace impossible.  

The truth is that the Jewish “settlers” have every right to inhabit the land of Judea.  The name alone, after all, strongly hints at a Jewish presence once upon a time.  

Shana Tova,

Ben       

New Year’s Greeting

As the sun is setting, marking the beginning of Rosh Hashana (The Jewish new year. Quite literally translated to: Head of The Year), I want to wish all of my Jewish and non-Jewish friends a metukah (sweet) coming year.  Please, whether Jewish or not, take time to think of your past misdeeds and actions you can perform in order to attempt to compensate for all you have done wrong.  EVERYBODY HAS DONE SOMETHING WRONG.  

I for one wish to grow stronger every day in my sense of Jewish identity.  I beseech each and every person (bloggers and non-bloggers alike) to consider who they are and what they want to be.  

Shana Tova (Have a good Year),

Ben Balderman

Brotherly love?

 

Brother,
 
I am not going to sugar coat everything and make believe that you have/are not hurting this family.  Obviously I am your younger brother and, therefore, do not expect you to truly understand or care about how I perceive your actions.  Either way, I am going to express myself, knowing full well that you probably will ignore my suggestions.  

You are a graduate of Kadimah school, NCSY, and Yeshiva University.  The last two listed are big parts of the greater Jewish Orthodox community.  As a graduate, it was obviously assumed that you would continue to shed a positive light to the rest of the world, not only about all Jews, but particularly about Orthodox Jews.  Rather, you abused drugs, became sexually promiscuous, and wear tattoos and piercings.  All mentioned are very anti-religious, which you, of course, know.  

Even disregarding all of the Jewish education YOU CHOSE to receive, you clearly did not learn and do not care about our family’s values.  All of our grandparents went through the Holocaust, yet still chose to keep Kosher, attend Shul regularly, and marry Jews.  Bubbi and Zayde wished for us to continue that tradition, and Nana and Grandpa wish for us to continue that tradition.  You certainly can, and most likely will, deny that you are clearly in the wrong.  You cannot deny, though, that our parents raised us to carry on our family’s long history of Jewish marriage and all that goes along with it.

Further, you are causing a majority of our parents’ stress, which is obviously terrible for their health (especially since our Father is a cancer survivor).  You know precisely what they wish of you before they are willing to truly communicate, so do not kid yourself in thinking there is a way around it.  You are not a martyr, no matter how much you pity yourself.  Stop sending them messages with false pretensions that you have changed.  You have not.  

It was just two weeks ago when you called my phone eight times within a five minute period.  Each time I picked up the phone and hung up immediately because I have no desire to communicate with such a self-loving person.  Nonetheless, I allowed your eighth attempt to go to voicemail.  Against my own advice I listened to a three minute rant in which you stated that “I am waiting for you to mature and accept me”,  “we will always be brothers and that’s just the way it is”,  and “I will always love you and you’re killing me.”  

It appears to me that you believe I have been ignoring you because our parents tell me to.  This is false.  I choose to not respond to your messages because I have set a moral standard for myself.  To revert back to my true self, after you warped my mind’s eye on almost all things (religion, relationships, family, drugs and alcohol), I began wearing a kippa in public.  I once again keep Kosher, only date Jewish girls, protect Shabbat, etc.  I do not wish to talk to you because of the adverse effect you had on my life and all you have done to our parents.  I am not certain that I will ever be able to truly forgive you fully, but I can promise you that the moment you marry that girl, I will cease to carry even the slightest hint of affection towards you.  If this adolescent behavior persists for too much longer, I will give up all hopes of once again having that older brother that I can look up to for guidance.

We will always be brothers by blood (there is nothing I can do about that), but genetics is not the definition of love.  Love is a single word that describes individual actions between a pair of people.  To simply state that you love our mother, our father, our sisters, our grandparents, or just that you love me is of no meaning when you went out of your way to leave this family.  Furthermore, I would hate for you to believe that simply breaking off the engagement with your fiance would suffice as an adequate apology for all you have done.  Doing so would not undo all of the tears shed, memories created, and mature life decisions I’ve been forced to make at my young age.  You had no fair reason to do what you have done.  All five of us siblings have been brought up under the same roof with the same rules. Your false justification that you were neglected does not give you moral authority to challenge these.

I do not care for your feeble excuses.  Dissimilar to you, I truly love both our mother and father with all of my heart, and wish them nothing but happiness for years to come.  Unlike you, I want to lead a Jewish life.  Contrasting to you, I do not use drugs, abuse alcohol, or wear tattoos and piercings.  Although it appeared almost inevitable that I would end up like you, I am nothing like you.  I think that it is time you start learning from your younger brother.

Ben
              

What about Judaism appeals to you and where do you see yourself going with it?
Anonymous

This is a good first prompt to be given after my summer long vacation from writing.  Anyway, much appeals to me about Judaism.  As you most likely read in many of my previous posts, there were multiple factors influencing my decision to become a modern Orthodox Jew; NCSY (National Council of Synagogue Youth-an Orthodox youth group), antisemitism, and my relative’s horrific actions.  

The appeal that Orthodox Judaism has to me in particular cannot be answered with one definitive remark.  I love the idea of being a leader of the Jewish people, I feel as if I serve an important service to all Jews and Israel, and I feel confident in knowing who I am.  Rather than living a “double life”, so to speak, I am now just myself wherever I go.  I believe that my Jewish and non-Jewish friends alike want to be around me much more than in the past.  

By the time I am an adult living on my own I hope that I stay true to the values I hold so dear now.  I hope to keep the Sabbath, eat Kosher, and follow as many applicable laws as possible.  

There is much more that I wish to say, but that would ruin the emphasis I wish to impose upon all of my readers in my next article. (Hint: It’s about my youth group-NCSY).    

Poll #1

Based off of title alone, which article would you like posted next?

1) Dating Jewish

2) Doesn’t Phase Me

Inbox me which one you’d prefer and I will post the one with the most votes by August 1st.

The winning article should be up soon after.

Stay tuned. 

Good job, Ben. This is really honest and heartfelt, and I like that. I really respect you for being able to write about your life in such a public setting. Aha this wasn't really a question so are you ok with everything that happened?

Am I okay with everything that has happened?  I wish I could say yes.  It hurts to lose friends over petty matters, most importantly those that you care so much about.  Above all, losing a close member of the family to drugs, lack of care, and narcissism is the worst.  On the other hand, if it weren’t for that event, I would not be the person I am today-although I wish I could have both.